| Year |
Coach |
School |
| 1971 |
Tom Sells |
Bloomington South |
| 1972 |
Bob Springer |
Indpls Washington |
| 1973 |
Jules Siegle |
E.C. Washington |
| 1974 |
Joe Talley |
Tell City |
| 1975 |
John Friend |
Munster |
| 1976 |
Tom Hession |
Shelbyville |
| 1977 |
Eldon Leeth |
Blackford |
| 1978 |
Jim Beldon |
Noblesville |
| 1979 |
Tony Berto |
Delphi |
| 1980 |
Bill Harrawood |
Boonville |
| 1981 |
Bill Griffith |
FW Wayne |
| 1982 |
Joe Goodman |
Seymour |
| 1983 |
Tom Conn |
Concord |
| 1984 |
Steve Purichia |
Indpls Chatard |
| 1985 |
Mark Hoffman |
Valparaiso |
| 1986 |
Joe Gengelbach |
North Posey |
| 1987 |
Mike Hawley |
FW Snider |
| 1988 |
Bob Gaddis |
Danville |
| 1989 |
Bob Bridge |
North Miami |
| 1990 |
Jerry Brewer |
Jasper |
| 1991 |
Brad Smith |
Crown Point |
| 1992 |
John Stafford |
Columbus East |
| 1993 |
Ted Huber |
Warsaw |
| 1994 |
Bob Copeland |
Danville |
| 1995 |
Mark Miller |
Rochester |
| 1996 |
Joe Purichia |
Washington |
| 1997 |
Russ Isaacs |
FW Snider |
| 1998 |
Mo Moriarity |
Bloomington South |
| 1999 |
Doug Denny |
Yorktown |
| 2000 |
Pat Malone |
Princeton |
| 2001 |
Scott Bovenkerk |
Jimtown |
| 2002 |
Keith Fiedler |
Carmel |
| 2003 |
Kirk Sorg |
South Adams |
| 2004 |
Mike Spencer |
Perry Central |
| 2005 |
Tim Roth |
Winamac |
| 2006 |
Danny Tieken |
Bloomington North |
| 2007 |
Tim Dawson |
Concord |
| 2008 |
Paul Loggan |
North Central |
| 2009 |
Bart Curtis |
Mishawaka |
| 2010 |
Mike Kirschner |
Ben Davis |
| 2011 |
Jeff Adamson |
Eastbrook |
| 2012 |
Reed May |
Brownstown Central |
| 2013 |
Jason Simmons |
Noblesville |
| 2014 |
Darrin Fisher |
Whiteland |
| 2015 |
Kurt Tippmann |
FW Snider |
| 2016 |
Toby Jacobs |
Hamilton SE |
| 2017 |
Bob Prescott |
Peru |
| 2018 |
Jake Gilbert |
Westfield |
| 2019 |
John Barron |
Plymouth |
| 2020 |
Travis Nolting |
Greenfield Central |
| 2021 |
Brett Colby |
Kokomo |
| 2022 |
Kevin O’Shea |
Twin Lakes |
| 2023 |
Keith Kilmer |
Lowell |
| 2024 |
Justin Dixson |
Decatur Central |
